The answers to clues on the first page fit in the blanks, with highlighted and unhighlighted blanks corresponding to consonants and vowels, respectively:
Adolescent = TEENAGER
Cattle feed = ALFALFA
Literally, “empty hand” = KARATE
“Stop it!” = ENOUGH
Watering hole = TAVERN
Actress Anne = HATHAWAY
Waste away = EMACIATE
Spot for a spit = ROTISSERIE
City visited by Dorothy = EMERALD
Untrue statement = FALSITY
Hamlet or Macbeth, e.g. (2 words) = LEAD ROLE
Okay to down = EDIBLE
Pocahontas locale = COLONY
Confused or disorderly = TUMULTUOUS
Genetic mutation or sorting algorithm = INSERTION
Last longer = OUTLIVE
Beginner or newbie = NEOPHYTE
The answers to the clues on the second page are in alphabetical order:
Fever condition = DELIRIUM
Exhaust or weaken = ENERVATE
Like Haile Selassie, LoLa Monroe, or Zahara Jolie-Pitt = ETHIOPIAN
Deep-fried ball = FALAFEL
Cleanliness = HYGIENE
Unwanted entrance = INTRUSION
"...nothing to fear but fear ______" = ITSELF
Lustful desire = LIBIDO
Grand and noble = LORDLY
Arise (from) = ORIGINATE
Result = OUTCOME
Component with colored bands = RESISTOR
One way to tie = STALEMATE
Bird country? = TURKEY
Action done when removing shoes or a corset = UNLACE
It's at the end of a rainbow? = VIOLET
Old british greeting (2 words) = WHAT HO
Given that the consonants are highlighted, we probably want to look at those, and indeed, these words can be paired up with the answers on the first page so that the consonants are in reverse order:
TEENAGER -> ORIGINATE
ALFALFA -> FALAFEL
KARATE -> TURKEY
ENOUGH -> HYGIENE
TAVERN -> ENERVATE
HATHAWAY -> WHAT HO
EMACIATE -> OUTCOME
ROTISSERIE -> RESISTOR
EMERALD -> DELIRIUM
FALSITY -> ITSELF
LEAD ROLE -> LORDLY
EDIBLE -> LIBIDO
COLONY -> UNLACE
TUMULTUOUS -> STALEMATE
INSERTION -> INTRUSION
OUTLIVE -> VIOLET
NEOPHYTE -> ETHIOPIAN
The first letters of the words on the left spell out TAKE THE REFLECTION, and the first letters of the words on the right spell out OF THE WORD ILLUSIVE. The solution is therefore a word whose consonants are VSLL in that order, and the only word which fits this pattern is VISUALLY.
(note: the Apprentice version of this puzzle was called “Professor Layton and the Heated Neonatal Irises of Europe”. This phrase's consonants form a palindrome.)